EVERYTHING
Max Winkler has established a significant presence in both independent film festivals and prestige television, moving from short features to directing major series for Netflix and FX/Hulu. According to Deadline, his recent work includes Monster: Ed Gein on Netflix and Love Story, which explores the romance and tragedy of JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette.
The Path to the Murphy-Verse
Winkler initially directed episodes of Feud: Capote vs. The Swans before finding a new direction. He was looking to reteam with Charlie Hunnam, who starred in Winkler's feature film Jungleland. Ryan Murphy recognized the duo’s desire for a substantial project and pitched them Monster: Ed Gein during a dinner meeting.
Winkler approaches Ed Gein’s story not just as a crime narrative but as another form of love story—one between "a son and his mother." Hunnam committed fully to method acting, developing a specific warbling accent for the isolated killer character. This role required immense physical dedication; Winkler noted that Hunnam lost approximately 40 pounds during production.
“We have a tremendous amount of trust for each other as two people who don’t trust a lot of people for whatever reason,” says Winkler. “He worked so hard... my job was just to give him the space to figure it out and to protect him.” — Max Winkler
Casting Challenges in High-Profile Dramas
Winkler also detailed his involvement with Love Story, where he stepped in to direct the New York City 1992 set pilot after Ryan Murphy had to depart at the last minute. While Sarah Pidgeon was already cast as Bessette, Winkler participated in the search for JFK Jr., alongside producers Brad Simpson and Nina Jacobson.
Casting JFK Jr. proved challenging because the character required a specific balance of traits. As Winkler explained, the actor needed to be:
- A movie star whom people are drawn to socially.
- Approachable, avoiding an overly polished image.
- Possessing a rugged quality without being too rough around the edges.
Anthony Kelly was ultimately chosen for the role of JFK Jr. Winkler highlighted that Kelly’s authenticity stood out during the casting process. He noted that Kelly was unpretentious and genuine, adding that he traveled with a shaggy service dog named Malcolm.
Winkler continues to expand his directorial scope within this genre, confirming plans for the next iteration of Monster: Lizzie Borden. His shift from indie filmmaking to television directing reflects a growing trend among acclaimed independent creators seeking larger platforms for their narrative visions.